Rock the Bass


photo by Jennifer Chrumka

How to Rock Part II: The Bass

The bass is cool. It doesn't get in your face, it doesn't preach, it doesn't fight for your attention. The bass just slides up and wraps its sound around your backbone, and before you even realize it you're hooked.

The bass player is an integral part of rock, and three of Vancouver's finest practitioners of the low gave me some insight into the craft: Barry Higginson from the Doers, Johnny Uljevic of Notes from the Underground, and Rebecca Stewart from Vancougar.

The Players

All three came to the bass from different directions, but there was never any doubt that bass was their destiny. Like many others, Barry came to the bass by way of the guitar. When his band's bass man didn't show up one day, Barry got his chance.

"There is something about the bass, I didn't choose it as a default," Barry said between sips from his beer. "I view my brief period as a guitar player as a happy accident to point me in the direction of bass...bass was the destination."

Johnny initially thought that drums were his thing back in high school. He saved up his cash from a gas station job to get a kit. But the drums were never meant to be; something always seemed to sidetrack him before he made a purchase. "One day I woke up and said, I'm going to buy a bass," Johnny recalled. "It just needed to happen."

Becca dug a little deeper when she reflected on her reasons for choosing bass. At first she wasn't so sure. But later, in the clatter of a pub, a realization dawned on her.

"Oh my God," she gasped, "I think I became a bass player because I'm a middle child with abandonment issues, and a bass player will never be abandoned." Then she turned to me with a resolute gaze, "Someone always wants a bass player."

Good bass players are indeed precious resources to be coveted and fought over. But it takes a certain type of person to really do bass. Johnny said that bass players are "people who don't mind minding the shop." Then he talked about cleaning up the shop, and keeping thieves away, and then...

"Like that post in a big tall building. It's hidden, you can't see the post, all you see is the nice decorations outside, nice looking girls going in and out, it's great!" said Johnny, his eyes wide.

"No one ever sees the post, but being the post is nice. First of all, no one bothers you. You just want to play, relax and take it easy. You don't want people to bother you, and it's nice." Becca and Barry echoed Johnny's perceptions of the bass player mentality...more or less.

Pluck versus Pick

"Nothing's wrong with picking, but if you're a good friend of mine and I've watched you do gigs..."

Barry told me of a fellow comrade in arms (who just happened to be Johnny), that used a pick maybe a little too much for a show. "I like to rib Johnny and I like to wag my finger and tell him to put the pick away," said Barry with a large, slightly tooth deficient grin. "Every once in a while a bass guitar needs to be played like a guitar, so there's nothing wrong with a pick. But if you really care about the bass and you really care about the sound, I think you'll eventually start plucking with your fingers."

Johnny filled me in later. "He came up to me after a show, and he's like, hey how's it going?" Johnny then pulled himself up in his chair, raised an inquiring eyebrow, and in his best Barry voice said, "used a pick eh?" and promptly burst out laughing.

"Class though, total class. A bit of concern, a bit of interest, wanted some answers, but without demanding them," said Johnny, still chuckling. "I just told him, I love the fingers, but once in a while a pick can be a lot of fun."

Becca doesn't do the pick thing at all, but it's not because she doesn't like the sound; in her case it's more about the feeling. "I think there is something tactile about it. I've tried playing with a pick and I always end up dropping it. It's like a barrier. It's like a condom...there's something about the feeling of it on my fingers," said Becca, once again pondering the inner workings of her bass motivations.

"Sometimes I wish I could do the pick thing for fast Dee Dee Ramone stuff...but it's not comfortable for me."

Gear

"Whatever looks nice and sounds nice to you, that's what you should have," said Johnny, and Barry and Becca pretty much agreed. A bass player's gear is a very individual thing, and largely depends on what kind of sound is desired. It takes a lot of time and experimentation to get to what's right for each player.

Barry's main advice was to "borrow people's gear as much as you possibly can, and then you'll start learning what can do what."

Becca got a little more particular. "Tube amp. An amp with tubes in is key for a big warm sound. And I think it's better to have a half stack rather than a combo amp, because with a combo amp, when one thing breaks the whole thing is broken."

Beginner Mistakes

Barry once again got philosophical when I asked him about common mistakes that bass players make when they're just starting out. "Maybe I'm just an optimist, but I don't tend to see flaws in their playing as mistakes so much as maybe they haven't learnt how to play it better yet," said Barry after a long ruminating pause.

"Most of the time they play it like a guitar. But that's how I started doing it too, so there's nothing wrong with that."

Barry also cautioned against getting too focused on gear. He explained that often beginners "get ahead of themselves by acquiring or desiring better gear when they have a hard time arpeggiating a chord or keeping time." No amount of gear, no matter how cool, is going to help you if you can't play the instrument.

In Becca's mind, the biggest mistake beginning players make is "trying to learn everything all by themselves and not jamming." She told me that learning how to play bass and make music depends on playing with other people. You have to get over sounding like crap at the beginning and just do it.

"It's like sex. If you play by yourself too much, you won't be able to play well with others."

Playing well with others is fundamentally what the bass player needs to be able to do in a rock band. Bass players are the hidden posts that make the foundation of rock. So if you think you've got what it takes, go get yourself a bass that sounds good, feels good and looks good, and do it!

But remember, it's more than a guitar, it's a bass guitar.

Barry gave me a good quote from Luke Rogalsky of Mystery Machine that sums it up: "Duh, one note at a time."

band

The Doers------------------Vancougar--------------Notes from the Underground

influences

Mike Watt--------------------Tina Turner--------------Cliff Williams
Charles Mingus-----------Ko Melina-----------------Duff McKagan

--

i published this article in the March issue of discorder

Replies
D
6 March 06

http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/11676209/

Whee!

D
8 March 06

http://www.galciv2.com/

D
9 March 06

http://www.gamespot.com/pc/strategy/warhammer/news.html?sid=6145679

D
9 March 06

http://www.gamespot.com/pc/rpg/ddonline/news.html?sid=6145431&mode=previews

jroy
9 March 06

yo D

how about commenting on the post instead of tempting me with computer games??

D
9 March 06

GalCiv2 is getting called the 'true' sequel to MOO2, J. Features full ship construction, control over planetary develop, and a very, very good AI system that doesn't cheat. It doesn't need to. Strong diplomacy system and multiple ways to win the game.

D
9 March 06

Oh, and your writing skills are improving. I remember when it was all "i r teh sciense gy."

v
12 March 06

You guys have no idea how many times I started writing posts about J's lack of writing skills (although we know he has it). But, being the guy who firmly posits that 'punctuation is for whimps' I felt it would be hypocritical. ;)

I'm around...I'll be around more in a bit (and J will have some shiny new toys too).

D
14 March 06

Sort of science journalism. Thought you might find it an interesting read, J, since it touches on the sort of work you'd like to do, though perhaps on a bit less technical, more 'meta' level.

http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/11786176/site/newsweek/

BottomDwellerFred
21 March 06

While many of the comments from the three selected bass players have merit and value, at times proved that "a little knowledge is a dangerous thing" ... worst case is simply more misguided fingers-bass-snobbery.

Not sure how musicians (young musicians especially) get these notions in their brain, but if you depend on them, your path in music will be misguided...at worst sound terrible, or not heard at all. Bass needs definition for it to effectively weave under the undulations of the guitar and drums. Bass needs to drive the air around everyone's backbone.

I respect their committment and passion for the bass, but question their self-imposed limitations. It depends so much on where you get (mis)information from. The best way is to use your ears and eyes: listening to and reading about as many bass players and bass styles as possible but not always believing the reverse-snobbery-hype of "fingers on bass"

a) you can't go by videos.
In music videos, every musician is hip. Hip to the point of gagging me. The perfect, right bass. The perfect, right finger stance. Lot of misinformation there. Listen to the records. Ask the engineers.

b) you can't go by Magnet interviews.
Interviews eventually turn into one-upmanship among musicians prone to pissing contests. John Smith mentions in the April issue that he's using fingers and this old Ampeg bass amp. In the May issue, Tim Jones mentions he only uses one finger and plays through Organe cabinets.

Myth: Tube Amps are Better for Bass.
Only for recording certain songs. Remember, when you go back and listen, the best bass recordings made were played through solid state Neve consoles and soild state amplifiers. Tubes are better for guitar. Soild state is better for bass. Avoid digital anything.

Remember: It's all bullshit. Don't buy into it.

Ask the engineers. Ask the soundmen. Picks are used on more records by more bass players than fingers. Direct signal to the board is used far more often than a microphone in front of a cabinet. Yes, miking a cabinet might be added into the mix.

But yer primary best bass sound is:
1) pick
2) direct box

Live is not much different ... in any gig where sound is important.

For some songs, yes, fingers sounds better and gives you more control. For most songs live, pick is the only way to get the best possible sound and tone.

Unless you're Flea or Jaco Pastorius or Duck Dunn or James Jamerson or Berry Oakley, stick to the pick. Your band will thank you. Your drummer will thank you. You'll get more gigs, you'll make more money.

.... but don't get me started ....

Best album ever for learning what a bass can do: Allman Brothers -Live at the Filmore. Forget about the 1970s vibe and feel. Forget about the blues. Just put this album on and only listen to the bass. It's all you need to know. It transcends all genres, all eras.

Myth: Bass is like Guitar.
No. Bass is not like guitar.
Lyrics are not poetry and bass is not guitar.
Bass is bass. Bass is BETTER than guitar. Don't let anyone tell you different. Bass drives the band way more than guitar or drums. Bass is the band. Think RHCP. Think U2. Think Motown.

Myth: Bass is a post that holds up the building. Wrong. Bass *IS* the building. Bass is the air inside that building, the air that breathes and sets the tone for the building. Anyway, building is the wrong analogy. Music is not constructed. Music is not concrete. Bass is air that moves people. Bass air moves more people than drums ever will. Drums are pretty boring. Bass moves people.

And less is always more with bass. When in doubt, play a half note instead of quarter. Leave more space than you take up. Leave no trace after the snare. When in doubt, don't play at all. Then come in thundering with your heart fully open and your eyes fully closed. All you need to know.

About to flame me? Bring it.

BottomDwellerFred
21 March 06

Oh yeah, the secret of bass is between 125hz and 250hz

jroy
21 March 06

nice!

i've gotta get barry and becca and johnny to respond!

skinhitter
22 March 06

Well BDFred, I've played bass and drums in various bands for, oh, 20 years now and I have to say I agree with you on the pick = definition part and most of the amplification suggestions. What I'm confused about is when you say "misguided fingers-bass-snobbery" but then get into some dogmatic 'bass is god' stuff at the end of your post. Not flamin', just saying watch the hypocracy, dude.

Oh, and nothing dictates the feel of a song like those boring drums ;)

barry doer
22 March 06

i once heard that all art criticism really boils down to 'i liked it' or 'i didn't like it'. i like my fingers. play how you like please, and i will use a pick, but not because it makes money.

skinhitter
23 March 06

BTW, nice troll

well well well
24 March 06

Bass is everything and nothing. It is what what you want and need it to be. Just like a pizza, everyone's different.

becca vancougar
3 April 06

"Remember: It's all bullshit. Don't buy into it."

I agree with you there. Otherwise your comment is a bit preachy. There are no absolutes when it comes to musical taste and everyones ear is different. I like what I like but I'm not going to force my opinion on anyone else. It has nothing to do with snobbery.

You are all kinds of wrong but only because you insist there IS a right and a wrong.

Comments have been closed